For
politicians on any level truth becomes only a matter of convenience
often measured on a scale of self-importance. As we head into
another round of Municipal elections this fact needs to be broadcast
loud and clear. In the real world of cities such as Toronto,
Hamilton and others media exists to provide information on all the
candidates. True, political bias and alliances are always evident in
media yet somehow all the information finds its way to the people in
the end. In St. Catharines, Ontario such a fantasy does not exist
and the so called media is at the helm of pseudo Spielbergs creating
illusion for sale to the local masses.
Politics
itself has always had an air of smoke and mirrors about it, at least
on a national level. After all a Prime Minister has to deal with
such mundane issues as national security, possible wars, terrorism
and more. Locally though it is hard to sell the need to have an
ability or finesse at a good poker face. Who would you need to
bluff? Homeowners who simply want decent roads so as not to lose
their teeth on the way to work? Residents who want water rates at an
affordable level and garbage collected?
Still
politics is politics and its allure of power changes even the
grassroots levels within its own sphere. Power in a big city is
equally big power, power in a small town is still big power and its
exhilarating effect impossible to ignore. Municipal politics remains
the most closely associated level in the political landscape with the
very people who elect their representatives. After all each resident
has an opportunity to cast a vote for a neighbour as their
representative on council.
As
the neighbours hit the streets with signs big and small, with
promises equally big and small, one most important point to remember
in the final decision process is that once they're in, they're in.
Lies, broken promises, even corruption doesn't matter, you
can't pry them out. Toronto has proven that insanity is the norm in
Canadian politics with the Ford farce.
St.
Catharines faces decision day on October the 27th
with five candidates for mayor elbowing and pushing for position.
Debates in Canada are moderated to remove all openness of debating.
Questions are sanitised and sterilised, and real truth non-existing.
Media in St. Catharines with its entrenched censorship ensures that
no facts are made public, no relevant or pertinent questions are
asked, and only harps on the negativity raised by candidates. It
seems in Canada candidates are only expected to say 'nice' things
about each other.
Looking
at the five mayoral candidates one soon realises that if this
Canadian civility is lifted to face reality and media censorship
smashed then the decision process is not an easy one. Borrowing
horse racing jargon, candidates Jim Fannon and Mark Stevens are
considered the less favourite with odds running against them for a
serious vote.
Candidate
Jim Fannon does not have a web page and no clear statement as to a
platform or 'wish list' for St. Catharines. He appears to run his
campaign through his Facebook and some of his statements make little
sense, in particular the notion of term limits. Term limits can only
be discussed at a provincial level and any decision making out of the
hands of municipal politicians. Originally Fannon was part of the
ra-ra team for the front runner candidate Jeff Burch and then decided
to run against him. When something like this happens questions arise
as to the real purpose of such a candidate.
Another
candidate, Mark Stevens, also faces extreme odds to find serious
voter numbers. Unlike Fannon, Mark Stevens has signs up all around
the city trying to compete on the well travelled intersections
littered with 'pick me' screams. Mark Stevens does have a web page,
he tries to say that he is only an ordinary guy who has lived in St.
Catharines for a long time and wants to make a difference. Listening
to Mark Stevens comment on jobs and the future of St. Catharines
proves that he is just a regular guy.
After
leaving behind the two outsiders what's left are the three prima
donnas elbowing for position and banging the drum of experience. Yet
a resume claiming experience also demands questions of consequence.
No such questions have been raised till now. If they are then the
spectre of negative campaigning is immediately pronounced. We in
Canada have to play nice and ignore the truth as it may be
uncomfortable.
Jeff
Burch, Peter Secord and Walter Sendzik each claim they have the
answers to the issues St. Catharines faces. Burch and Secord both
have sat on city council taking part in the decisions and responsible
for inaction that has provided for a very uncomfortable future for
this city and its people. Walter Sendzik has led the Greater Niagara
Chamber of Commerce and watched the decimation of the city core with
no real answers as to any potential solutions. Now these three have
found the light and are willing to sell their sideshow.
Walter
Sendzik claims to want “transparency
and accountability at city hall.” Each
time there is an election, wannabe politicians pick up the same tired
and useless words. Somehow desire for transparency and
accountability only surfaces before they get elected; once in office
the doors are shut. Being the leader of a Chamber of Commerce, it is
no surprise that Sendzik also employs another tired and common slogan
in his desire to “identify
and remove barriers to business.”
Yet he stayed silent when business owner Sam Demita, owner and
operator of Sun Collision not only removed so called barriers but
simply broke all the by-laws without consequence.
Once
again each of the candidates is on the GO Train election ride and
promises to rebuild Port Dalhousie. Reality rarely joins in the
lists of promises and empty words. In his “vision
for St. Catharines,” Walter
wishes to “focus
on returning St. Catharines as a leader in Ontario.” To
“focus on returning” would insinuate
that
St. Catharines once lead the province in some area, he does not make
that clear though.
St. Catharines downtown core is
barely limping. All the promises of good times to come with the
massive building of two facilities are yet to eventuate. Bringing in
residential space opens the doors to questions of services for the
basic needs such as some sort of supermarket. The core has plenty of
bars, a fancy, new and elaborate tattoo parlour and a hamburger joint
that sends the Big Mac packing. But no one can lay claim to the
illusion that 'the core' is residence friendly. Oh and that has not
been a secret over the last four years.
Poverty and struggle for survival
in St. Catharines is a daily routine. Our job market is
non-existent. Those who are fortunate to have jobs find themselves
in the minimum wage or barely above bracket, unable to provide the
bare basics for their families. Young people who were born here have
no reason to stay and if it continues, that in itself will forecast a
loss of identity and credibility.
Walter
makes empty promises and then when pressured on issues as head of the
chamber he blames the board for its decisions. One could take
Sendzik's “vision” and pull it to pieces for saying nothing built
in reality but that would be considered as pessimistic by Canadian
standards. Yet Sendzik himself admits to horrific figures for
unemployment, for youth unemployment and how low St. Catharines was
rated by the Conference Board of Canada Report of 2014. The report
titled City Magnets III: Benchmarking the Attractiveness of
50 Canadian Cities, analyses and
benchmarks the features that make Canadian cities attractive to
newcomer populations. Cities are compared on indicators grouped
into seven categories: Society, Health, Economy, Environment,
Education, Innovation, and Housing. Data for this analysis is based
on the 2011 Census and National Household Survey.
No one can ignore these
realities.
In
an interview with The Standard (Walter Sendzik says city's
future is in jobs. Karena Walter, October 9, 2014) Sendzik
said; “the next 10 years has to be about attracting
private sector investments in the community. That's where my
background provides a lot of expertise in getting the private sector
spending in the community, investing in the community.” So
the man who led the Chamber of Commerce, a man who now lays claim to
a background and expertise in getting things done within the private
sector saw no reason to do any of this until he declared his
political intentions. Where did Walter Sendzik hide his expertise
whilst head of the Chamber of Commerce? Why is it only now in an
election campaign that Sendzik brags about his expertise, maybe his
salary as the head of the chamber wasn't enough motivation to attract
private sector spending.
Sprinting
from the Sendzik vision one crashes into Peter Secord and his ideal
of 'Back to Basics'. Peter Secord claims that he is ready to be
mayor after years of serving on city council. As a councillor Secord
has been present for all that has happened in St. Catharines. He
claims, “After significant citizen-led investment in our
community, St. Catharines must ensure its finances are in
order and in line with our community's new priorities.” Our
community's new priorities? Unemployment, poverty, our young
leaving, taxes, lubricious spending by Church Street, simple honesty
and integrity in office, are these to be considered “new
priorities”?
According
to Peter Secord's great stride into the future he wants to “get
back to the basics of representing the taxpayer. Our community needs
someone who not only understands the issues but has lived through
them as well.” What is
Secord's version of back to basics?
Peter Secord sat on city council as fellow councillor Jeff Burch
lied to council. Secord knew that Councillor Jeff Burch lied, he
also was provided with the Integrity Commissioner's report where
Suzanne Craig clearly stated that she had not cleared Burch of the
very serious allegations. Maybe honesty, integrity or accountability
do not rate high in Peter Secord's back to basics.
What
does rate as back to basics
to Peter Secord? As he was aware of Councillor Jeff Burch's lies, as
a fellow member of council he was also aware of a small business
owner Sam Demita, owner and operator of Sun Collision, who had broken
local laws for some 5 years. Secord is also aware that after the
city 'fixed' the law for Sam Demita, and after an OMB hearing cleared
the path, the same Sam Demita has broken the new laws that the city
had fixed for him.
Peter
Secord has a 1, 2, 3 step plan for his back to basics:
First is, “A plan for financial accountability,” then
the Second is, “Local solutions for local jobs,” and
finally the Third, “Commitment to the taxpayer.”
Reading these steps or points
little is found that is constructive or realistic. In his first
installment Secord speaks of a tax freeze, he actually promises one.
If he was to win the job as mayor, Peter Secord will be only one vote
and he has heard loudly from council that the majority are against
such folly.
In
his second installment Secord is surprised that “the same
team who is responsible for business support also oversee the Santa
Claus Parade and Canada Day events.” Where
has Secord been for his years of service on council? This is news to
him? Maybe it was Santa Claus who 'fixed' things for Demita?
In
the 2010 election Brian McMullan said no tax dollars should be spent
on the hockey palace. Peter Secord sat on council and approved the
exact opposite. Now it is the same Secord who promises a tax freeze.
A little too little and a little too late. Yet at a council meeting
when his plans for a tax freeze were openly objected, Peter Secord
said that nothing was set in stone. Secord finished off with this in
relation to his motion on freezing taxes, “The motion is
just that staff works in that direction, towards zero, it's setting
the bar, so that they go in that direction.” (Doug Herod,
www.stcatharines.ca, October 1 2014, 'HEROD: Hamming it up on council
stage').
Has the proverbial bar been set or
will the final candidate in the 2014 Municipal elections find a new
level for himself? Jeff Burch, like Peter Secord, has sat on city
council for years, and like Peter Secord has only now found the
answers. Unlike Secord, Jeff Burch points to 5 Priorities for
Prosperity and welcomes people to the “new St. Catharines”
on his billboards whilst the old St. Catharines has not been
buried in the aftermath of the election stampede.
Burch's five priorities for
prosperity in fact do not really sound any different from Secord
or Sendzik. Jobs, or the frightening lack of, are on the minds of
all residents in St. Catharines. Tax dollars have never left the
minds of St. Catharines residents as each year it is becoming harder
and harder to budget for the inevitable increases. Whether it is
Burch and his five or Secord with desires of going back to basics, or
Sendzik's vision, Port Dalhousie is a hot topic. The Go Train is on
everyone's wish list even if there are no real riders for it and our
downtown still waiting for solutions.
Reading Jeff Burch's press releases
or his website, nothing new is found. On October 1st a
press release on Port Dalhousie finds Jeff Burch quoted as saying “I
have the experience to lead revitalization efforts that respect and
include residents.” From here the bar is lowered dramatically
and the similarities between Burch and the other two main candidates
cease.
Integrity Commissioner Suzanne
Craig came to investigate Councillor Jeff Burch and his lies to City
Council and the people of St. Catharines. Integrity Commissioner
Craig was shocked that no one from The Standard or the free
Niagara this Week made any reference to the investigation.
Councillor Jeff Burch lied to protect Sam Demita, owner and operator
of Sun Collision. In the end Integrity Commissioner Craig submitted
her report and stated that she had not cleared Councillor Jeff Burch
of the very serious allegations. All of this was censored.
This was not all that Councillor
Burch has never answered for. As residents in Merritton found
flooding damage in their homes, Councillor Burch issued a warning to
one of the residents that was chilling. To keep things quiet
Councillor Burch in the 2010 election campaign used Niagara Regional Police to harass and intimidate me so as to stop any questions being
raised. Everything here has been documented and it's only the
censorship by The Standard in particular that has kept this
from the people of St. Catharines. Now ex-reporter from The
Standard Marlene Bergsma has publicly endorsed Burch.
Residents all over will struggle to
make a decision as to who they should vote for. In St. Catharines
there are extremely serious issues and the political game surrounding
all the candidates continues. The Conference Board of Canada
released its report in Ottawa September 18th 2014, and
rated St. Catharines in the 'D' Cities – Struggling to Attract.
One of the main criteria for consideration according to Alan Arcand
of the Centre for Municipal Studies is, “cities that fail to
attract new people will struggle to stay prosperous and vibrant.”
St. Catharines found itself in the “D” class where 9 of the
13 cities had showed little population growth between 2006 and 2011,
and two cities saw their population decline. (News Release 15-27
Six Canadians Cities out of 50 Receive Top Marks for Attracting
Newcomers).
According to Statistics Canada, St.
Catharines' population in 2006 was 131,989 and in 2011 it dropped to
131,400. Both Jeff Burch and Peter Secord have sat on city council
since 2006. “Now is not the time for campaign stunts”, these
are Jeff Burch's own words. Now is the time to
make a very hard decision and live with it for the next four years.
Send comments to: demtruth@gmail.com
No comments:
Post a Comment